commodities · Global · Monthly Free

Combining momentum with reversal in commodity futures

Academic paper

AuthorsRobert J. Bianchi; Michael E. Drew; John Hua Fan

Institute

Griffith University

Paper linkhttps://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbankfin.2015.07.006

Teaser

Enter when short-horizon z-score is deeply negative; exit near zero. Universe: GLD, SLV, DBC, GSG, USO, UNG, DBA. Parameters: lookback=20; entry_z=-1.0; exit_z=0.0; rebalance=daily. Rebalanced on the engine's template schedule with 5 bps commission and 2 bps slippage. Because the paper's primary signal (ML, sentiment, or proprietary data) is not available in our public ETF engine, this draft uses a liquid ETF rule that preserves the paper's economic theme rather than a bit-exact replication.

Strategy in a nutshell

This paper examines profitable trading strategies that jointly exploit momentum and reversal signals in commodity futures. While the single-sort momentum strategies returns 11.14% per annum, on average, a consistent reversal pattern of momentum profits is pronounced from 12 to 30 months after portfolio formation. Combining the observed reversal pattern with the momentum signal, our double-sort strategy returns 20.24% per annum, which significantly outperforms single-sort strategies. The proposed strategy is robust to seasonality effects and sample adjustments in commodity futures. The profitability of the double-sort strategy cannot be explained by standard risk factors, term structure, market volatility, investor sentiment, data-mining or transaction costs, but appears to be related to gl

Economic rationale

Short-horizon overreaction produces temporary dislocations that reverse toward a local mean. Related evidence from “Combining momentum with reversal in commodity futures”: This paper examines profitable trading strategies that jointly exploit momentum and reversal signals in commodity futures. While the single-sort momentum strategies returns 11.14% per annum, on average, a consistent reversal pattern of momentum profits is pronounced from 12 to 30 months after portfolio formation. Combining the observed reversal pattern with the momentum signal, our double-sort strategy returns 20.24% per annum, which significantly outperforms single-sort strategies. The proposed

Entry & exit

Entry

Compute a 20-day z-score on each name in GLD, SLV, DBC, GSG, USO, UNG, DBA. Enter when z ≤ -1 (stretched to the downside).

Exit

Exit when the z-score mean-reverts back to ≥ 0. Positions are not held through a full trend — only the snap-back.

Market data required

Needs at least 25 adjusted daily closes on GLD, SLV, DBC, GSG, USO, UNG (+1 more) before the first signal is ready. ETF columns print on exchange sessions only. The lab loads Yahoo Finance via backtest.data.load_daily_prices.

Symbols

GLD, SLV, DBC, GSG, USO, UNG, DBA

Frequency

Monthly · Daily adjusted close; signals rebalance on the month change (last available session)

History needed

≥ 25 trading days per symbol (about 2 months), plus a few extra bars so the first signal can fire.

Fields

Adjusted close (Yahoo auto_adjust)
Session date index

Credentials

None for paper and the onsite lab
Broker or exchange API keys only for live orders

APIs & providers

Quant Buffet Data API

The lab calls load_daily_prices for the ASSETS panel of adjusted closes, then caches CSV so backtests replay the same series.

Provider: backtest.data.load_daily_prices
Auth: None for paper / sandbox backtests
Endpoints: load_daily_prices(ASSETS, start="2000-01-01")

API / docs → /en/docs/data-api

Yahoo Finance via yfinance

US equities and ETFs, adjusted OHLCV, free for research (rate limits apply).

Provider: yfinance → Yahoo Finance
Auth: None for public history
Endpoints: Ticker.history / yf.download(auto_adjust=True)

API / docs → github.com/ranaroussi/yfinance

Onsite backtest IDE

Quant Buffet native backtest IDE

Edit and run Quant Buffet Python for Combining momentum with reversal in commodity futures in the browser. Results update live with equity, drawdown, and metrics charts. Allowed: backtest.data, backtest.engine, backtest.metrics, numpy, pandas. Define ASSETS and make_on_day(prices). Shortcut: Ctrl+Enter. API docs →

IDE · 44 lines

"""
Quant Buffet interactive lab — combining-momentum-with-reversal-in-commodity-futures
Allowed: backtest.data / backtest.engine / backtest.metrics, numpy, pandas.
Required: a module-level ASSETS list, and def make_on_day(prices) returning (on_day, ready)
"""
from __future__ import annotations

import numpy as np
import pandas as pd

from backtest.data import load_daily_prices
from backtest.engine import EngineConfig, PortfolioEngine
from backtest.metrics import compute_metrics

ASSETS = ['GLD', 'SLV', 'DBC', 'GSG', 'USO', 'UNG', 'DBA']
LOOKBACK = 20
ENTRY_Z = -1.0
EXIT_Z = 0.0

def make_on_day(prices: pd.DataFrame):
    cols = [c for c in ASSETS if c in prices.columns]
    mu = prices[cols].rolling(LOOKBACK, min_periods=LOOKBACK).mean()
    sd = prices[cols].rolling(LOOKBACK, min_periods=LOOKBACK).std(ddof=0)
    z = (prices[cols] - mu) / sd.replace(0, np.nan)
    held = {s: False for s in cols}

    def on_day(engine: PortfolioEngine, dt: pd.Timestamp) -> None:
        long = []
        for s in cols:
            zv = z.at[dt, s]
            if pd.isna(zv):
                continue
            if not held[s] and zv <= ENTRY_Z:
                held[s] = True
            elif held[s] and zv >= EXIT_Z:
                held[s] = False
            if held[s]:
                long.append(s)
        w = {} if not long else {s: 1.0 / len(long) for s in long}
        engine.set_target_weights(dt, w)

    ready = z.dropna(how="all").index.min() if z.notna().any().any() else None
    return on_day, ready

"""
Quant Buffet interactive lab — combining-momentum-with-reversal-in-commodity-futures
Allowed: backtest.data / backtest.engine / backtest.metrics, numpy, pandas.
Required: a module-level ASSETS list, and def make_on_day(prices) returning (on_day, ready)
"""
from __future__ import annotations

import numpy as np
import pandas as pd

from backtest.data import load_daily_prices
from backtest.engine import EngineConfig, PortfolioEngine
from backtest.metrics import compute_metrics

ASSETS = ['GLD', 'SLV', 'DBC', 'GSG', 'USO', 'UNG', 'DBA']
LOOKBACK = 20
ENTRY_Z = -1.0
EXIT_Z = 0.0

def make_on_day(prices: pd.DataFrame):
    cols = [c for c in ASSETS if c in prices.columns]
    mu = prices[cols].rolling(LOOKBACK, min_periods=LOOKBACK).mean()
    sd = prices[cols].rolling(LOOKBACK, min_periods=LOOKBACK).std(ddof=0)
    z = (prices[cols] - mu) / sd.replace(0, np.nan)
    held = {s: False for s in cols}

def on_day(engine: PortfolioEngine, dt: pd.Timestamp) -> None:
        long = []
        for s in cols:
            zv = z.at[dt, s]
            if pd.isna(zv):
                continue
            if not held[s] and zv <= ENTRY_Z:
                held[s] = True
            elif held[s] and zv >= EXIT_Z:
                held[s] = False
            if held[s]:
                long.append(s)
        w = {} if not long else {s: 1.0 / len(long) for s in long}
        engine.set_target_weights(dt, w)

ready = z.dropna(how="all").index.min() if z.notna().any().any() else None
    return on_day, ready

Quant Buffet syntax cheat sheet (copy / insert)

Paste these fragments into the editor. The sandbox rejects QuantConnect, os, and network libraries.

Required imports

Only these libraries are allowed in the sandbox.

from __future__ import annotations

import numpy as np
import pandas as pd

from backtest.data import load_daily_prices
from backtest.engine import EngineConfig, PortfolioEngine
from backtest.metrics import compute_metrics

ASSETS list (whitelisted ETFs)

Module-level list. Tickers must be in the Quant Buffet whitelist.

ASSETS = ["SPY", "QQQ", "TLT", "GLD", "BIL"]

make_on_day contract

Must return (on_day, ready). on_day calls engine.set_target_weights.

def make_on_day(prices: pd.DataFrame):
    cols = [c for c in ASSETS if c in prices.columns]
    sma = prices[cols].rolling(200, min_periods=200).mean()
    state = {"last": None}

    def on_day(engine: PortfolioEngine, dt: pd.Timestamp) -> None:
        if sma.loc[dt].isna().all():
            return
        key = (dt.year, dt.month)
        if state["last"] == key:
            return
        state["last"] = key
        long = [
            s for s in cols
            if pd.notna(prices.at[dt, s]) and pd.notna(sma.at[dt, s])
            and prices.at[dt, s] > sma.at[dt, s]
        ]
        weights = {} if not long else {s: 1.0 / len(long) for s in long}
        engine.set_target_weights(dt, weights)

    ready = sma.dropna(how="all").index.min() if sma.notna().any().any() else None
    return on_day, ready

Set target weights

Weights should sum to about 1.0. Empty dict = 100% cash.

engine.set_target_weights(dt, {"SPY": 0.60, "BIL": 0.40})

Live backtest performance

CAGR

-7.24%

Sharpe

-0.19

Max DD

-94.18%

Vol

24.34%

Sortino

-0.28

Beta

0.34

Stored preview only. Run backtest to simulate every daily session from Yahoo Finance adjusted closes.

Run the backtest to load orders, then mark them on the equity chart.

Equity curve (indexed = 100)

Accent = strategy · dashed grey = buy-and-hold benchmark. Hover or tap any point for its date and values.

Drawdown

Metrics bar chart

Monthly returns

Order records

Run the backtest to load every order fill alongside performance.

Export to your platform

Transform Quant Buffet lab code (ASSETS + make_on_day / PortfolioEngine) into native classes for a third-party IDE — then copy and paste.

Target platform

Run in: QuantConnect Cloud or LEAN CLI · QCAlgorithm with Equity securities and monthly rebalance.

Detected pattern: Mean reversionAssets: GLD, SLV, DBC, GSG, USO, UNG, DBA

# Generated from Quant Buffet → QuantConnect LEAN
# Strategy: Combining momentum with reversal in commodity futures
# Detected pattern: Mean reversion
# Source uses Quant Buffet lab APIs (ASSETS + make_on_day / PortfolioEngine).
# Review fees, data, and risk before live trading — educational export only.

from AlgorithmImports import *


class QuantBuffetExport(QCAlgorithm):
    def Initialize(self):
        self.SetStartDate(2010, 1, 1)
        self.SetCash(100000)
        tickers = ["GLD", "SLV", "DBC", "GSG", "USO", "UNG", "DBA"]
        self.symbols = []
        for t in tickers:
            if "-" in t:  # crypto proxy e.g. BTC-USD
                self.symbols.append(self.AddCrypto(t.replace("-USD", ""), Resolution.Daily).Symbol)
            else:
                self.symbols.append(self.AddEquity(t, Resolution.Daily).Symbol)
        self.Schedule.On(
            self.DateRules.MonthStart(self.symbols[0]),
            self.TimeRules.AfterMarketOpen(self.symbols[0], 30),
            self.Rebalance,
        )
        # Logic: Buy when return z-score < -1 over 20 days.

    def Rebalance(self):
        import numpy as np
        picks = []
        for symbol in self.symbols:
            hist = self.History(symbol, 20 + 5, Resolution.Daily)
            if hist.empty: continue
            close = hist["close"]
            if hasattr(close, "unstack"):
                close = close.unstack(level=0).iloc[:, 0]
            rets = close.pct_change().dropna()
            if len(rets) < 20: continue
            window = rets.iloc[-20:]
            z = (window.iloc[-1] - window.mean()) / (window.std() or 1e-9)
            if z < -1:
                picks.append(symbol)
        w = 1.0 / len(picks) if picks else 0.0
        for symbol in self.symbols:
            self.SetHoldings(symbol, w if symbol in picks else 0.0)

Exported code uses the platform’s native classes and libraries. Install dependencies in your third-party IDE, then run. Validate before live trading.